QUOTE (ricky @ Oct 6 2009, 05:19 AM)

In brief, can TT come to swallow his pride and sign some FA OL players who can protect Rodgers? Ron Wolf always regretted not giving Favre enough weapons. Rodgers has the weapos, he simply doesn't have the time. I fully realize that TT has given a lot of attention to the OL in the past few drafts. The result is dismal. Enough. Strike now. Spend some money.
I think this (the bolded section) raises a good question. It's an old question; the arguments are always the same; viewpoints rarely if ever change. But still....
Why are the results dismal?
Is it really talent? Does Thompson really consistantly draft the wrong linemen; should those guys really be compared so harshly against their peers coming out of college?
Let's look at Alex Smith and Aaron Rodgers. Rodgers fell in the draft, but does that really mean he compares so badly with Alex Smith talentwise? On the other hand, Rodgers is turning into a franchise QB and Alex Smith has been an utter flop, so the shoe's on the other foot - but again, is that really because the innate talent in Alex Smith compares so poorly with the innate talent in Aaron Rodgers?
I don't agree with this static view of such intangibles as talent. And I seriously wonder what the real problem is with our linemen. If Thompson
and his entire scouting staff simply cannot spot line talent, then there it is. But there could be other reasons and those reasons are far too infrequently explored, imo. And even when they are, by the very next post in most cases, it's as if such comments have not been made at all.
I still think most fans are too hasty in their heads - they arrive at conclusions too rapidly, without effective analysis. They always remind me of people who return puppies because they pee on the floor; returning them as if they don't work properly. It's a good thing for most of us that parents don't think that way - at least not entirely, not enough to abandon us completely. Even though they may be our fans.