I get to keep 8 players in my keeper league. I won the title this year. (its an 8 team league)

Donovan McNabb
Shaun Hill

Clinton Portis
Brandon Jacobs
DeAngelo Williams
Maurice Jones Drew
Steven Jackson

Larry Fitzgerald
Andre Johnson
Roddy White
Braylon Edwards
Bernard Berrian

I hate to cut McNabb as it is a qb heavy league and it would be hard for me to get a quality quarterback. One team has Rivers, Cutler, and Rodgers. He is a hard guy to trade with though. I offered him Portis and Edwards for any one of them and I havn't gotten an answer yet.

So I am thinking on keeping McNabb, Jacobs, Williams, Drew, Jackson, Fitzgerald, Johnson, and White.
I think White has more upside than Portis.

Jesus that team is stacked.

How many people are in your league?

I think the eight you selected are probably the right choices, by the way.

well if you must keep mcnabb.. then here are the other 7

Portis
Jacobs
SJax
Deangelo
Fitz
AJ
Roddy White

For some reason I put Portis is the LT category, their best is behind them. Jones - Drew has been consistent in scoring, but hasn't proven to be a 20-25 carry guy. He does score touchdowns though, but just may not have that good a rushing average. This was actually the hardest decision, Portis, or Jones-Drew.

I'd keep Portis over Steven Jackson. I think Braylon Edwards will rebound next year. Might keep him over any QB on your team.